RAID ARRAYS -- Redundant Arrays of Inexpensive Discs
RAID arrays can be set up as a Windows feature or via a hardware RAID cluster
controller to provide enhanced performance, fault tolerance, or both.. The
hardware solution will provide higher performance and is the better choice for
high end applications. RAID arrays are configured after the basic Windows
installation and prior to the installation of applications or loading of data.
The relevant RAID configurations are discussed below:
RAID 0 - Disc Striping
Disc striping provides faster data throughput by distributing the load across
multiple discs in a sequential fashion. An array of three 100GB discs provides
300GB of total storage and since all three discs are accessed simultaneously,
access time is slightly more than 1/3 that of the same drives operating
independently. The downside is that a failure of any one disc in the array
renders all data lost. Raid 0 is most appropriate where performance is critical,
there is little transaction processing and an alternate method of fault
tolerance is provided.
RAID 1 - Disc Mirroring
Disc mirroring involves provisioning a pair of discs on one disc controller.
Each write to the master disc is subsequently written to the slave disc and
provides an exact duplicate. Upon failure of the master disc, the slave can
serve as an immediate replacement by either a hardware cable swap or by a drive
reconfiguration in the operating system. When the defective disc has been
replaced, the mirror can be reestablished to resume fault tolerant operation.
The downside of this configuration is that a failure of the disc controller
renders both drives inaccessible. An array of two 100GB discs will provide
100GB of total storage. Read access will be the same as for a single
un-arrayed disc, however write time will be double because of the double write
requirement. Raid 1 is most appropriate for servers where maximum fault
tolerance is critical and the loss of performance is acceptable. Log files
should always be mirrored.
RAID 1 - Disc Duplexing
Disc duplexing involves provisioning a pair of discs on two disc controllers.
Each write to the master disc is subsequently written to the slave disc and
provides an exact duplicate. Upon failure of the master disc, the slave can
serve as an immediate replacement by either a hardware cable swap or by a drive
reconfiguration in the operating system. When the defective disc has been
replaced, the mirror can be reestablished to resume fault tolerant operation.
The advantage over mirroring is that a failure of one disc controller doesn't
render both drives inaccessible. An array of two 100GB discs will provide
100GB of total storage. Read access will be the same as for a single
un-arrayed disc, however write time will be double because of the double write
requirement. Raid 1 is most appropriate for servers where maximum fault
tolerance is critical and the loss of performance is acceptable. To minimize
performance loss, purchase the fastest discs and controllers available. Log
files should always be mirrored.
RAID 5 - Disc Striping with Parity
Disc striping with parity provides faster data throughput with some fault
tolerance. The data is distributed across multiple discs as with Raid 0,
however, an additional disc is added to store parity information. With
this setup, any one disc in the array can be rebuilt from the parity bits but
the loss of two discs results in total data destruction. An array of three
100GB discs provides 200GB of total storage since the third discs only holds
parity information. Larger arrays are more efficient than smaller arrays (ten
100GB discs yields 900GB) and possibly faster performance depending on the drive
controllers. Raid 5 is most appropriate where performance is critical and
transaction processing is a greater share of server load than is the case of
Raid 0 because of its increased fault tolerance. An alternative method of fault
tolerance is advisable. To minimize performance loss, purchase the fastest discs
and controllers available.
RAID 10 - Disc Striping with Mirroring
Disc striping with mirroring is a greatly enhanced solution. Two arrays of discs
are striped for maximum performance as with Raid 0 and then duplexed for maximum
fault tolerance as with Raid 1. The performance loss of duplexing is offset by
the performance gain of striping but the drive count is high resulting in low
storage efficiency. Six 100GB discs yield a total storage capacity of 300GB.
Ultimate Solution
A excellent solution for a high performance, maximally fault tolerant single
server would entail setting up two duplexed discs for the operating system,
applications, and log files using
the internal EIDE buss. Then use a hardware RAID SCSI controller to provision a
cluster of discs for bulk database storage.
A high end solution would likely entail a cluster server to provide load
sharing or failover, two or more SQL servers, and a shared NAS array.
|